Otsego, NY 13326 5211 State Highway 28

5211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 15211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 25211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 3
37 more
5211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 45211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 55211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 65211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 75211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 85211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 95211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 105211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 115211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 125211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 135211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 145211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 155211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 165211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 175211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 185211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 195211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 205211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 215211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 225211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 235211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 245211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 255211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 265211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 275211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 285211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 295211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 305211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 315211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 325211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 335211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 345211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 355211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 365211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 375211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 385211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 395211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 405211 State Highway 28 Otsego, NY - Image 41
Presented By: Michele M. Barry with Cooperstown Brokers, LLC;
  • MLS# R1721922
  • 10/26/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 3
  • Baths • 4
  • SQFT • 2,768
  • Garage • 2

Home Details

Timeless Grandeur. Bespoke Living. A Home of True Distinction. Exquisitely restored to its original grandeur in 2018, this distinguished circa 1880 brick residence in Cooperstown, New York, is a rare expression of historic elegance and modern luxury. Rich in character yet thoughtfully reimagined for today’s lifestyle, the home blends timeless architectural beauty with refined finishes, updated systems, and exceptional comfort. Four fireplaces lend warmth and ambiance throughout, while three beautifully appointed primary suites offer luxurious accommodations and privacy. The spacious kitchen serves as the heart of the home, perfectly suited to both intimate gatherings and gracious entertaining. A comprehensive restoration brought new life to this historic residence, incorporating all-new systems while honoring the craftsmanship and enduring appeal of its nineteenth-century origins. Set on three picturesque acres overlooking the pastoral landscape of Grasslands Farm, the property offers a captivating sense of space, serenity, and connection to the countryside. A newly constructed two-car garage adds modern convenience, and complements the home’s timeless architecture. Here, historic distinction meets contemporary sophistication in one of Cooperstown’s most compelling settings. More than a home, this is a bespoke lifestyle—defined by architectural heritage, understated luxury, and the pleasure of living beautifully.
Presented By: Michele M. Barry with Cooperstown Brokers, LLC;

Interior Features for 5211 State Highway 28

Bedrooms

Main Level Bedrooms0
Total Bedrooms3

Bathrooms

Half Baths0
Main Level Bathrooms1
Total Baths4

Other Interior Features

Air Conditioning Y/NYes
BasementFull
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Fireplace Y/NYes
FlooringHardwood, Varies
Heating Y/NYes
Interior AmenitiesSeparateFormalDiningRoom, EatInKitchen, SeparateFormalLivingRoom, CountryKitchen, KitchenIsland, PullDownAtticStairs, InLawFloorplan
Laundry FeaturesMainLevel
Total Fireplaces4
Total Stories2

General for 5211 State Highway 28

AppliancesDoubleOven, Dryer, Dishwasher, ElectricCooktop, Microwave, OilWaterHeater, Refrigerator, Washer
Architectural StyleColonial, HistoricAntique
Attached Garage No
CityOtsego
Construction MaterialsBrick, Frame, SprayFoamInsulation, PexPlumbing
CoolingHeatPump, Zoned, CentralAir
CountyOtsego
DirectionsFrom the village of Cooperstown, head south on Rte 28. Property sits on the right across from the Clark Grasslands farm.
Elementary School DistrictCooperstown
Full Baths4
Garage Spaces2.0
Garage Y/NYes
HeatingHeatPump, Oil, Zoned
High School DistrictCooperstown
LevelsTwo
Lot Size Square Feet130680.0
Lot Size UnitsAcres
MLS AreaOtsego-365089
Middle/Junior School DistrictCooperstown
Number Of Units Total
Patio/Porch FeaturesPatio
PossessionCloseOfEscrow
Property ConditionResale
Property SubtypeSingleFamilyResidence
Property TypeResidential
RoofArchitectural, Shingle
School DistrictCooperstown
Security FeaturesRadonMitigationSystem
Senior Community Y/NNo
SewerSepticTank
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Stories Count2
Tax Annual Amount7542.0
Tax Assessed Value413000
Tax Lot46
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount0.0
Total Rooms11
TownshipNot Applicable
UtilitiesHighSpeedInternetAvailable
Year Built1880
Year Built DetailsExisting

Exterior for 5211 State Highway 28

Building Area Total2768.0
Exterior AmenitiesGravelDriveway, Patio
Foundation DetailsStone
Lot Dimensions228X659
Lot FeaturesIrregularLot, NearPublicTransit
Lot Size Acres3.0
Lot Size Area3.0
Parking FeaturesDetached, Garage
Road Frontage TypeMainThoroughfare
Water SourceWell
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Mark Siwiec

CEO
Price $1,100,000
MLS#R1721922
List Date 10/26/2026
Property Type Single Family
Phone
Request Tour
Request Info

Similar Properties to 5211 State Highway 28