Pittsford, NY 14534 3551 Monroe Avenue

3551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 13551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 23551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 3
18 more
3551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 43551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 53551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 63551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 73551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 83551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 93551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 103551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 113551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 123551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 133551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 143551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 153551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 163551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 173551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 183551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 193551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 203551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 213551 Monroe Avenue Pittsford, NY - Image 22
Presented By: Jeremy V. Havens with Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates;
  • MLS# R1712959
  • 09/17/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 4
  • Full/Half Baths • 1 / 1
  • SQFT • 2,500

Home Details

Welcome to 3551 Monroe Avenue, a truly memorable four-bedroom home where craftsmanship, character, and an extraordinary origin story come together. Built by a teacher alongside his students, the home reflects a level of care and detail that still defines it today, from rich hardwood floors and substantial woodwork to exposed ceiling beams and beautifully preserved architectural elements throughout. The main level is anchored by a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, creating a warm and inviting place to gather. The living room flows naturally into the formal dining room, where French doors open to a three-season room that feels like an extension of the living space and offers a wonderful setting for relaxed mornings or enjoying the surrounding greenery. The kitchen, a first-floor bedroom, and a convenient half bathroom complete the main level while adding valuable flexibility to the layout. Upstairs, three additional bedrooms continue the home’s classic character with hardwood floors and generous natural light, along with a full bathroom. The partially finished basement provides even more usable space for recreation, hobbies, a home gym, or whatever fits your needs. Outside, the home sits on an expansive lot framed by mature trees, offering an impressive amount of lawn and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. With its remarkable history, timeless craftsmanship, generous living spaces, and beautiful setting, 3551 Monroe Avenue is the kind of home that feels special the moment you walk through the door and becomes even more compelling the more you discover.
Presented By: Jeremy V. Havens with Elysian Homes by Mark Siwiec and Associates;

Interior Features for 3551 Monroe Avenue

Bedrooms

Main Level Bedrooms1
Total Bedrooms4

Bathrooms

Half Baths1
Main Level Bathrooms1
Total Baths2

Other Interior Features

Air Conditioning Y/NYes
BasementFull, PartiallyFinished
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Fireplace Y/NYes
FlooringHardwood, Tile, Varies
Heating Y/NYes
Interior AmenitiesCeilingFans, SeparateFormalDiningRoom, EntranceFoyer, SeparateFormalLivingRoom, NaturalWoodwork, BedroomOnMainLevel
Laundry FeaturesInBasement
Total Fireplaces1
Total Stories2

General for 3551 Monroe Avenue

AppliancesDryer, Dishwasher, ElectricOven, ElectricRange, GasWaterHeater, Refrigerator, Washer
Architectural StyleHistoricAntique
CityPittsford
Construction MaterialsBrick
CoolingCentralAir
CountyMonroe
Elementary School DistrictPittsford
Full Baths1
Garage Spaces0.0
Garage Y/NNo
HeatingGas, ForcedAir
High School DistrictPittsford
LevelsTwo
Lot Size Square Feet47916.0
Lot Size UnitsAcres
MLS AreaPittsford-264689
Middle/Junior School DistrictPittsford
Number Of Units Total
PossessionCloseOfEscrow
Property ConditionResale
Property SubtypeSingleFamilyResidence
Property TypeResidential
School DistrictPittsford
Senior Community Y/NNo
SewerConnected
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Stories Count2
Tax Annual Amount7757.0
Tax Assessed Value179400
Tax Lot34
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount0.0
Total Rooms9
TownshipNot Applicable
UtilitiesSewerConnected, WaterConnected
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1920
Year Built DetailsExisting

Exterior for 3551 Monroe Avenue

Building Area Total2500.0
Exterior AmenitiesBlacktopDriveway
Foundation DetailsBlock
Lot Dimensions133X369
Lot FeaturesRectangular, RectangularLot
Lot Size Acres1.1
Lot Size Area1.1
Parking FeaturesNoGarage
Road Frontage TypeMainThoroughfare
Water SourceConnected, Public
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Jeremy Havens

Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker
Price $399,900
MLS#R1712959
List Date 09/17/2026
Property Type Single Family
Phone 585.507.9325
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Mark Siwiec

CEO
Price $399,900
MLS#R1712959
List Date 09/17/2026
Property Type Single Family
Phone 585.330.8750
Request Tour
Request Info

Similar Properties to 3551 Monroe Avenue